NMPA asks judges for MLC v. Spotify documents as Amazon seeks lower songwriter rates
Publishers want bundle evidence in the 2028-2032 rate case, where four services want current terms kept and Amazon wants a 13.4% headline rate.

The National Music Publishers' Association and the Nashville Songwriters Association International have asked the US Copyright Royalty Board to force the release of documents from the Mechanical Licensing Collective's lawsuit against Spotify, according to a filing reported by Digital Music News on November 18. The documents bear on how streaming services read the royalty rules they now want to carry into 2028 to 2032.
The request matters because the rate case, known as Phonorecords V, has narrowed to a fight over bundles. Of the five streaming companies that filed proposals, four want the current terms kept and one, Amazon, wants a cut. The publishers want almost everything raised. We covered the opening positions on November 1; this is what has moved since, and what each side is asking for in detail.
What the subpoena is after
The MLC sued Spotify, claiming it underpaid mechanical royalties after it reclassified its Premium plan as a bundle once audiobooks were added. Bundles carry a lower payment formula than standalone subscriptions. The NMPA says the documents exchanged in that case show how services interpreted core terms in ways that reduced what songwriters receive, and calls them highly relevant to Phonorecords V.
The judges turned down an earlier version of the request before the rate proposals were filed. The NMPA says Spotify will not hand the material over voluntarily and that a subpoena is needed because of a protective order in the MLC case. As a fallback it asks that Spotify be ordered to produce everything exchanged by any party or non-party in that litigation. Discovery in the MLC case is wrapping up, and the MLC has had some setbacks there, Digital Music News reported. The article gives no court, dollar figure or trial date.
Four services stand still, Amazon asks for less
The baseline is the Phonorecords IV settlement. The headline rate is 15.3% of service revenue in 2026 and 15.35% in 2027. A standalone subscription pays the higher of that figure or 26.2% of what the service pays labels, or $1.10 per subscriber, with a 60-cent floor. Bundles pay 24.5% of label payments with a 33-cent floor.
Spotify wants those terms unchanged through 2032 and calls the Phonorecords IV deal the best evidence of what a willing buyer and seller would agree. Apple asks the board to adopt that settlement outright and says bundle discounts were essential to its agreement. Google, for YouTube, also asks to keep the rates, plus a rule that pays only on the share of plays a licence covers and the removal of app store fees and carrier charges from royalty revenue. Pandora wants the rates kept and four narrower changes, including excluding fraudulent accounts from user counts.
Amazon is the outlier. It proposes a 13.4% headline rate, label-payment share of 22.8% and $0.96 per subscriber, with a 52-cent floor. For bundles such as Amazon Music Unlimited it would drop the revenue test and pay 21.3% of label payments with a 29-cent floor. For Prime Music it asks for 22.8% and a 22-cent floor. Amazon argues it should not pay royalties on revenue it never receives.
The publishers' four-part formula
The NMPA and NSAI want services to pay the greatest of four amounts: 20% of revenue, 40% of label payments, $2.40 per subscriber or $0.004 per play. The per-subscriber and per-play figures would rise with inflation, and the per-play rate would apply to free, ad-supported tiers.
They also ask for the end of family and student plan discounts, for each simultaneous-play account to count as a separate subscriber, and for zero-rated free trials to go. Bundle components would have to be sold at genuine market prices. A separate group led by the Songwriters Guild of America and Eight Mile Music Companies proposes a flat $0.003 per stream from 2028, adjusted for inflation, with testimony from Bernie Taupin. Services have cited NMPA figures showing US publishing revenue rose from $5.6 billion in 2022 to $7.3 billion in 2025 to argue that the current deal works.
Why the bundle documents carry weight
The NMPA says Spotify's bundling cost publishers nearly $480 million, using Spotify's own estimates, and could pass $3.1 billion through 2032 if the rules stay as they are. Spotify introduced the bundle treatment in 2024, and Amazon later adopted a similar approach. If the judges see how Spotify and its counterparties read the bundle terms in private, the publishers can argue the current wording does not do what the settlement implied.
A ruling for the publishers on the subpoena would not decide the rate. It would put evidence on the record that Spotify has so far kept behind a protective order.
The calendar to December 2027
Amended direct statements are due on December 21, 2026, and responses on February 1, 2027. Settlement talks are set for January 25 to February 15. Without a deal, hearings run from March 22 to April 15, 2027, and the judges are due to issue an initial determination by December 17, 2027.
What does each service cost right now? See our streaming price tracker.



